Deck Painting vs. Staining: Which Is the Right Finish?

Choosing between deck paint vs. stain can be challenging since both finishes are appealing and durable. Finishing protects wooden decks from moisture damage, snow, UV rays, and other outdoor elements. This article covers the key differences between paint and stains to help you pick the best finish for your deck.

---

Painting Your Deck

Painting your old deck can give it a new look and hide any imperfections in the wood. Deck paint expands and contracts with temperature changes, resisting fading, cracking, scuffing, and peeling. When choosing deck paint, it’s important to consider the quality, color, finish, and maintenance.

Types of Paints for Decks

1. Acrylic-Based Paint

Acrylic deck paint is made up of acrylic resin. It’s a quick-drying water-based paint containing low volatile organic compounds (VOCs). This type of deck paint suits homeowners looking for environmentally friendly paint. While not as durable as oil-based paint, acrylic paint is cheaper.

2. Oil-Based Paint

Oil-based deck paint is popular for its durability and protection against weather elements. It’s resistant to UV rays, moisture, and mildew, making it suitable for exposed decks. Oil-based paints retain their color for many years, so you don’t have to repaint your deck often.

But, oil-based paints take longer to dry and have a strong odor that lingers for days. They also release more volatile organic compounds (VOCs) than water-based options.

3. Latex Paint

Latex paint is water-based, low-VOC, and quick drying. It protects against UV rays and resists cracking and chipping in hot climates. Choose latex paint if you want non-toxic and DIY-friendly paint. Its major drawback is poor color retention, so you may have to repaint it often.

Pros and Cons of Deck Painting

Pros:

• Lasts longer: A good quality paint job lasts up to 10 years without reapplication. Latex paints are most durable in hot climates, while oil-based paints offer the best protection against moisture.
• More color choices: Deck paints are available in various colors and finishes. From bold to neutral shades, you can choose a deck color that complements your home’s exterior.
• Smooth, uniform appearance: A fresh coat of paint can seal any cracks and imperfections on the deck. Deck painting is more suitable for a modern, clean aesthetic.
• UV protection: Paint forms a protective barrier on the deck’s surface, shielding it from the sun’s rays. This protection helps prevent wood fading and discoloration of the deck’s surface.

Cons:

• Slippery surface: Glossy deck paints create a smooth surface that may become slippery when wet. Opt for other finishes for rainy locations and near swimming pools.
• Labor intensive: Painting a wooden deck involves surface preparation, treatment with a wood preservative, and priming. You also need to add two coats of paint and seal with clear polyurethane.
• Costly installation: High-quality deck paints are most expensive than stains. Also, the need for touch-ups and repainting increases the long-term cost of deck painting.
• Prone to cracking and staining: Harsh weather conditions and poor application of deck paint causes peeling and chipping. High foot traffic and accidental spills can cause discoloration, which ruins the deck’s appearance.

---

Staining Your Deck

Deck staining is applying a finish to the surface of wooden decks to protect them from moisture damage, UV rays, and other elements. Unlike deck painting, which creates a solid color barrier on the surface, deck stains enhance the natural beauty of the wood.

Different types of deck stains include oil-based stains, water-based stains, epoxy-fortified, and transparent stains. The choice of stain type and color depends on the desired level of transparency or opacity.

Types of Stains for Decks

1. Transparent Stains

Transparent stains provide minimal color change, allowing the wood grain and texture to show through clearly. Wood stains best suit new or well-maintained decks with minor surface damage.

2. Semi-Transparent Stains

These stains offer more color than transparent ones but allow the wood grain to show through. Semi-transparent stains offer better UV protection and water repellency, which protects the deck from mold and mildew. They’re suitable for decks with some imperfections and aging but still want to preserve the wood’s natural look.

3. Solid-Color Stains

Solid-color or opaque stains contain a lot of pigment, which hides the wood’s natural grain and texture. They’re available in various colors that effectively hide imperfections in the deck. Choose this type of deck or porch stain if you want a new, bold look for your home’s exterior.

4. Epoxy Stains

Epoxy stains have a deep sheen similar to traditional oil-based finishes. They’re very durable, hence suitable for decks exposed to heavy foot traffic or harsh weather.

Pros and Cons of Deck Staining

Pros:

1. Enhances the natural aesthetics of the wood: Deck staining is an excellent way to maintain the natural appearance of the wood while protecting it from damage.
2. Better protection from moisture: Stains penetrate the wood and form a protective film, which prevents water from soaking into the deck.
3. Requires less frequent application than paint: Deck stains are less prone to peeling and cracking, unlike paint. Deck staining is generally more cost-effective than other deck finishing options.

Cons:

1. Less effective in concealing imperfections: Unlike paint, staining doesn’t conceal cracks or holes on wooden decks.
2. Limited color options: Most stains match the natural color of wood. The standard wood stain colors are cherry, mahogany, walnut, ebony, and cedar.

Painting vs. Staining: Key Differences to Consider

Deck finishing is usually the last step in building a deck. It’s advisable to wait 30 days after installation for the deck to soak up the paint or stain. Comparing different wood finishes is essential when choosing a finish for your deck.

Natural Aesthetics

Staining showcases the natural beauty of the wood grain and provides a rustic look. On the other hand, painting gives a smooth and uniform finish that can help hide inconsistencies in the wood.

Cost

Deck staining is cheaper than painting, with most stain brands costing between $20 and $90 per gallon. You can estimate how much stain you need on the deck stain calculator. Pre-stain treatment is simple and inexpensive, depending on your deck’s state.

Expect to pay between $30 to $60 per gallon of deck paint and $15-$30 per gallon of primer. You must also factor in other costs such as labor, deck repairs and replacement, and wood preservative.

Availability of Color Choices

While deck paints are available in bold red, green, yellow, and blue shades, most stain brands come in natural wood tones. Nonetheless, modern decks incorporate gray, white, black, green, and blue wood stains. Custom color matching is more common with paints.

Ease of Application

Deck stain’s thinner consistency and reduced surface preparation make it easier to apply than paint. Unlike paints, staining does not require a primer; most transparent types provide enough coverage with one coat. Solid-color stains also dry faster than paint, allowing you to apply multiple coats on the same day.

Durability

Deck paint and stains offer great durability and protection from elements. But, if you’re comparing deck paint vs. stain, paint comes out as a more durable and colorfast finish. Good quality deck paint lasts for ten years or more. Stains fade over time and may need re-application every 1-3 years.

Ease of Maintenance

Paint forms a uniform layer that’s easy to dust or sweep clean. Stained decks, however, need more effort to clean and may get damaged by heavy scrubbing. Touch-ups are usually more straightforward for stained decks that show signs of wear or minor damage. Unlike paint, you can reapply the stain to affected areas without extensive preparation.